Skip to content
Gifts

How to Choose Romantic Jewelry

Choose jewelry to suit your partner's style, with guidance on metals, gemstones, settings, personalization and everyday care.

Gold necklace with a rose quartz pendant in an open blush velvet jewelry box

Choosing jewelry for someone you love is easier when you know what to look for. This guide covers the main types of jewelry, the metals and gemstones they are made from, how stones are set, ways to add a personal touch, and how to shop for and care for what you buy.

Choosing the Perfect Type of Jewelry

When it comes to choosing the perfect piece of jewelry for your loved one, there are a few things to consider. First and foremost, you should think about her personal style. Does she prefer classic, timeless pieces, or does she like to stay on top of the latest trends? Understanding her style will help you select a piece that she will truly love and cherish.

Next, think about her preferences. Does she have a preference for a certain type of jewelry, such as rings, necklaces, bracelets, earrings, anklets, or charms? Taking her preferences into account will ensure that you choose a piece that she will enjoy wearing and feel comfortable with.

It is also worth choosing a piece with personal meaning, such as a birthstone, an engraved message, or a symbol of a milestone in your relationship.

Lastly, consider the occasion for which you are gifting the jewelry. Is it for a birthday, anniversary, or another important event? Consider the significance of the occasion and choose a piece that reflects it appropriately. Many anniversaries also have a traditional gem or metal: silver for the 25th, pearl for the 30th, ruby for the 40th, sapphire for the 45th, gold for the 50th and diamond for the 60th.

Understanding Different Types of Jewelry

Jewelry comes in a wide variety of types, each with its own unique characteristics and appeal. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most popular types of jewelry:

Rings

Rings are a timeless symbol of love and commitment. They come in various styles, including engagement rings, wedding bands, and cocktail rings. Rings can feature a single gemstone, a cluster of stones, or a simple and elegant band.

Necklaces

Necklaces are a versatile piece of jewelry that can be worn with any outfit. They come in a range of lengths and styles, from delicate chains to statement pendants. Necklaces can be adorned with gemstones, pearls, or even personalized with initials or a special pendant.

Bracelets

Bracelets are a beautiful way to adorn the wrist and can be stacked or worn individually. They can be simple chains, charm bracelets, or bangles. Consider her wrist size and whether she prefers delicate or bold designs when choosing a bracelet.

Earrings

Earrings are a classic accessory that can instantly elevate any outfit. From simple studs to elegant drop earrings, there are endless options to choose from. Consider her preference for studs or dangle earrings, and whether she prefers gold or silver tones.

Anklets

Anklets are a unique and trendy piece of jewelry that adds a touch of bohemian charm to any look. Whether she prefers a delicate chain or a more detailed design, anklets are a fun and unexpected choice.

Charms

Charms are a popular choice for bracelets and necklaces. They can be personalized with meaningful symbols, initials, or birthstones, making them a great way to create a piece of jewelry that is truly one-of-a-kind.

Pendants

Pendants are a versatile piece of jewelry that can be worn on a necklace or added to a charm bracelet. They come in various shapes and sizes, allowing you to choose a pendant that reflects her personal style and interests.

Choosing the Right Metal

The metal of a piece of jewelry can greatly impact its overall look and durability. Here are some of the most common metals used in jewelry:

Gold

Gold is a classic choice for jewelry and comes in a variety of colors, including yellow gold, white gold, and rose gold. Pure gold does not tarnish, but it is very soft, so jewelry is made from gold mixed with other metals. The karat number shows how much gold is in a piece: 14K is 58.3% gold and 18K is 75%. Higher karat gold has a richer color but is softer, which is why 14K is often chosen for everyday rings.

Silver

Silver is a versatile metal that can be polished to a high shine or oxidized for a more vintage look. It is more affordable than gold but can be prone to tarnishing over time. Regular cleaning and maintenance can help keep silver jewelry looking its best.

Platinum

Platinum is a rare, dense metal with a naturally silvery-white color. Platinum jewelry is typically 90 to 95% pure, which makes it a good choice for sensitive skin. It still scratches, but the metal is displaced rather than lost, and it develops a soft patina that can be polished away.

Rose Gold

Rose gold has gained popularity in recent years for its warm and romantic appearance. It is created by mixing gold with copper, which gives it a pinkish hue. Rose gold is a beautiful alternative to traditional yellow or white gold.

White Gold

White gold has a similar appearance to platinum but is more affordable. It is created by mixing gold with white metals such as palladium or nickel, and is often coated with rhodium for a bright, white finish. The rhodium wears off over time, and a jeweler can re-plate the piece. If she has sensitive skin, ask whether the alloy contains nickel.

Simple gold ring in an open velvet box

Deciding on Gemstones

Gemstones add color and sparkle to jewelry, making them a popular choice for many. Here are some of the most popular gemstones used in jewelry:

Diamonds

Diamonds are a classic choice for engagement rings and are known for their brilliance and hardness: they rate 10, the top of the Mohs scale, though a sharp knock can still chip one. They come in various shapes, including round, princess, and emerald, and can be set in a variety of styles. Diamond is the birthstone for April.

Sapphires

Sapphires come in every color except red (red corundum is a ruby), with blue the most popular. They have traditionally stood for loyalty and truth, and they are often used as a center stone in engagement rings or as accents in other jewelry pieces. Sapphire is the birthstone for September and the traditional gem for a 45th anniversary.

Rubies

Rubies are a rich red gemstone traditionally linked with passion and love. Ruby is red corundum, the same mineral as sapphire, and it is the birthstone for July and the traditional gem for a 40th anniversary. Rubies are a popular choice for statement rings and can also be paired with diamonds or other gemstones for a striking contrast.

Emeralds

Emerald is the green to bluish-green variety of the mineral beryl, and it is the birthstone for May and the traditional gem for a 55th anniversary. Emeralds are often treated with oil or resin to improve their clarity, so avoid ultrasonic and steam cleaners. They are often set in vintage-inspired designs or as accents in other jewelry pieces.

Opals

Opals are known for their play of color, flashes of rainbow hues that shift as the stone moves. They are softer and more fragile than most gems and can crack with sudden temperature changes, so they suit pendants and earrings better than a ring worn every day. Opal is the birthstone for October.

Pearls

Pearls are a timeless and elegant choice for jewelry. They come in various shapes and sizes, including classic round pearls and baroque pearls, which are irregular in shape. Natural pearls form without any human help and are rare. Cultured pearls, including freshwater pearls, are grown on pearl farms and are much more affordable. Pearl is the birthstone for June and the traditional gem for a 30th anniversary.

Amethysts

Amethyst is the purple variety of quartz and the birthstone for February. It has traditionally been linked with calm and a clear mind, and at 7 on the Mohs scale it is hard enough for everyday jewelry.

Considering Jewelry Settings

The setting of a piece of jewelry refers to how the stones are secured in the metal. Here are some common jewelry settings to consider:

Prong setting

A prong setting uses small metal prongs to hold the gemstone in place. This setting allows for maximum light to enter the stone, maximizing its brilliance. Prong settings can be simple or elaborate, depending on the design.

Bezel setting

A bezel setting involves a metal rim that completely surrounds the gemstone, holding it securely in place. This setting offers a sleek and modern look while providing excellent protection for the gemstone.

Channel setting

A channel setting involves placing multiple gemstones side by side within a channel of metal. This creates a seamless and continuous line of stones, often used in wedding bands or eternity rings.

Pavé setting

A pavé setting involves small gemstones set closely together and held by tiny beads or prongs, creating a surface that appears to be “paved” with stones. This setting adds sparkle and texture to a jewelry piece and is often used on ring bands, around a center stone, and in earrings and pendants.

Tension setting

A tension setting involves the use of pressure to hold the gemstone in place. The metal band is carefully designed to create tension, securely gripping the gemstone. This setting creates a modern and minimalist look.

Choosing Jewelry with Sentimental Value

Adding a personal touch to jewelry can make it even more special. Here are some ways to choose jewelry with sentimental value:

Engraving

Consider having a piece of jewelry engraved with a special message, date, or initials. This adds a personal touch and can turn a beautiful piece of jewelry into a cherished keepsake.

Birthstones

Incorporating birthstones into a piece of jewelry is a meaningful way to represent loved ones. Whether it’s a necklace with the birthstones of family members or a ring with your loved one’s birthstone, it adds a personal touch and symbolizes special connections.

Custom-made designs

Opting for custom-made jewelry allows you to create a piece that is completely unique and tailored to your loved one’s tastes and preferences. Work with a jeweler to design a one-of-a-kind piece that reflects her individual style.

Loose gemstones

Consider purchasing loose gemstones to have them incorporated into a piece of jewelry later on. This gives you the flexibility to create a custom piece down the line, allowing for maximum personalization.

Pearl drop earrings and a thin gold chain on linen

Deciding on Jewelry Brands

The brand of a piece of jewelry can add prestige and value. Consider the following types of jewelry brands:

High-end luxury brands

High-end luxury brands are known for their craftsmanship, quality, and iconic designs. These brands usually cost more, and part of the price is the name, so compare the metal, stones and craftsmanship with other sellers at a similar price.

Boutique and independent designers

Boutique and independent designers offer unique and one-of-a-kind pieces. These designers often have a distinctive style and can offer a more personalized shopping experience.

Handmade and artisan jewelry

Handmade and artisan jewelry is made in small batches or one piece at a time, so you can often learn who made it and how. That story can make it a meaningful gift.

Considering Budget and Quality

When choosing romantic jewelry, it’s important to set a budget and consider the quality and craftsmanship of the piece. Here are some points to keep in mind:

Setting a budget

Decide on a budget that you are comfortable with before starting your search. This will help narrow down the options and prevent overspending. Remember that it’s possible to find beautiful and meaningful pieces in a range of price points.

Considering quality and craftsmanship

When assessing the quality of a piece of jewelry, pay attention to the materials used and the attention to detail in the craftsmanship. Look for well-made settings, secure clasps, and smooth finishes. Check the stamp that shows the metal: in the U.S., gold is marked with its karat (such as 14K), sterling silver with 925 or sterling, and platinum with Plat. or Pt. A stamp on gold or silver should come with the maker’s registered mark.

Balancing price and value

While it’s important to consider your budget, don’t solely focus on price. Instead, consider the value that the piece of jewelry will bring to your loved one. A piece that holds sentimental value or is crafted with exceptional quality may be worth the investment, even if it comes with a higher price tag.

Shopping from Trusted Sources

When purchasing romantic jewelry, it’s essential to shop from trusted sources to ensure authenticity and quality. Here are some reputable options to consider:

Reputable jewelry stores

Established jewelry stores with a good reputation are a reliable choice for quality and authentic pieces. Ask for a clear written description of the metal and stones. For a diamond, ask for a grading report from an independent lab such as GIA.

Online retailers and marketplaces

Online retailers and marketplaces offer a wide variety of jewelry options from different sellers. When shopping online, make sure to research the seller’s reputation and read customer reviews to ensure a positive buying experience.

Certified jewelers

Certified jewelers have undergone training and have the knowledge and expertise to provide guidance when choosing jewelry. They can help you understand the different qualities of gemstones and metals and assist in finding the perfect piece.

Read customer reviews

Before you buy, check recent customer reviews for how the seller handles returns, resizing and repairs, and read the return policy yourself.

Taking Care of Romantic Jewelry

Once you’ve chosen the perfect piece of romantic jewelry, it’s important to take proper care of it to keep it looking its best. Here are some tips for cleaning, maintenance, and storage:

Cleaning and maintenance tips

Regularly clean your jewelry using a mild soap or specialized jewelry cleaner. Use a soft brush to gently scrub the piece, paying attention to crevices and settings. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that could damage the jewelry. Pearls, opals and emeralds need extra care: wipe them with a soft, slightly damp cloth, and never soak them or use an ultrasonic or steam cleaner.

Proper storage

Store your jewelry in a clean and dry place, preferably in a jewelry box or pouch to prevent scratching and tangling. Keep necklaces and bracelets separate to avoid them getting tangled. Protect valuable pieces by storing them in a safe or a locked drawer.

Avoiding contact with chemicals

Remove your jewelry before swimming, showering, or engaging in activities that involve chemicals or harsh substances. Chemicals in chlorine, detergents, and beauty products can cause damage to the metal and gemstones over time.

Regular inspections

Regularly inspect your jewelry for any signs of wear or damage. Inspect the prongs holding the gemstones to ensure they are secure. If you notice any issues, take your jewelry to a professional jeweler for repair or maintenance.

Start with her style and what she already wears, add a detail that means something to the two of you, and look after the piece once she has it.

Related reading: Handmade Gift Ideas For A Personal Touch, Luxurious Romantic Gift Ideas For 2024 and DIY Gift Ideas For Her.